Search

Listing Board: Key West Association

Current Price: $6,449,000

Listing Date: 2026-10-08

List Price: $6,449,000

KW Neighborhood: Old Town-N of Truman

City: KEY WEST

Mile Marker: 2

Marathon Neighborhood: N/A

Side: Median

Flood Zone: 0.2 PCT ANNUAL CHANC

Alternate Key #: 1025518

Parcel #: 00024730-000000

Zoning: HMDR - Historic Medium Density Residential

Deed Restrictions: Unknown

Legal: KW W C MALONEY DIAGRAM PB1-22 LOTS 12-14 SQR 2 TR 7 OR214-574/75 OR486-674 OR680-791/92 OR1581-531/32 OR2439-1422/26 OR2

Taxes: 16005.43

Tax Year: 2025

Pub Sewer HkUp: Yes

Street #: 1311

Street Name: Truman

Street Suffix: Avenue

Key/Island: Key West

State/Province: FL

Zip Code: 33040

County: Monroe

Subdivision: W C Maloney Diagram (2.0)

Area: 01 - Key West

Realtor.COM Type: Residential - Single Family

Waterfront: No

Control Depth: 0

Lot Size: X

Lot SqFt: 14490

Pool: Yes

Lot Sqft Source: Property Data Card

Total Units: 0

Acres: 0.33

SqFt Source: Property Data Card

Rentals Allowed: With Restrictions

Min Rental Days: 30

Style: Single Family

Year Built: 1900

Living Apx SqFt: 4306

Total Bedrooms: 7

Full Baths: 7

Half Baths: 1

Total Baths: 8

Remarks – Consumer: Some Key West homes are historic because they are old. 1311 Truman Avenue is historic because of who built it, who gathered within its walls, and who saved it. Its front door came from the Old Southernmost House. Past it, Dade County pine flows through every room, chandeliers light high ceilings on both floors, and the original staircase still rises where it has stood for more than a century. A second staircase toward the rear, also original to the house, recalls the scale on which it was built. Outside, sweeping double-story porches wrap the Victorian-influenced home, set on a third of an acre. The house was built at the turn of the twentieth century by Benjamin Douglas Trevor and his wife, Mary Fogarty Trevor. Mr. Trevor founded Key West's first Steam Laundry and in 1903 became Mayor of Key West. In the decades that followed, the house became home to the Key West Woman's Club and later served as a church. In 1975 two prominent local antique dealers purchased it and returned it to its original glory, and their work received the first award for an excellent restoration given by the Old Island Restoration Foundation. That restoration still defines the house. The original windows remain, along with the moldings and trim, and verandas open to the grounds from both floors. A large covered porch offers room for both dining and living, with views over the refinished pool and the guest cottage. Over the past decade, the current owners have carried that stewardship forward. A magnificent tropical garden and a stunning pool now grace the 14,490-square-foot lot. Every bathroom has been updated and finished in a fine selection of marble, granite, and quartz, and the kitchen and appliances have been updated, bringing modern comfort to a house whose history remains its defining feature. Built by a mayor, gathered in by the Woman's Club, and saved by the restoration that set the standard for Old Town, 1311 Truman Avenue is ready for the next chapter of its story.

Directions: On Corner of Truman Ave and Florida St.

Mandatory Home Owners Asc: No

1st Right of Refusal: No

Association Fee $: 0

# of City License: 2

None: 1

None: 1

None: 1

Dishwasher: 1

Dryer: 1

Gas Appliances: 1

Microwave: 1

Oven: 1

Range: 1

Refrigerator: 1

Stainless Steel Appliance(s): 1

Washer: 1

Pets Allowed: 1

Central Air: 1

None: 1

No Waterview: 1

Marble: 1

Tile: 1

Wood: 1

Built-in Cabinets: 1

Dade County Pine: 1

Drapes/Blinds Incl: 1

Security System: 1

Smoke Alarms: 1

Storage: 1

Walk-in Closet(s): 1

Window Treatments: 1

Updated/Remodeled: 1

Above Flood: Yes

French Doors: 1

Wood Windows: 1

Car(s): 1

Carport: 1

Off Street Parking: 1

On Premises System: 1

Frame: 1

1/4 - 1/2 Acre: 1

Negotiable: 1

FKAA: 1

Deck: 1

Open Porch/Balcony: 1

Patio: 1

Detached Guest Qtrs: 1

Fencing: 1

Lighting: 1

Privacy Wall/Fence: 1

Shed: 1

Sprinkler System: 1

Storage: 1

In Ground: 1

Concrete: 1

Metal Roof: 1

Panel: 1

Status: Active